Our Favorite Cake Flavors

Our Favorite Cake Flavors on wetakethecake.com

The votes are in.

The options of cake and frosting flavors at We Take The Cake are evolving and growing every day. With our team members working around the clock to sweeten and delight each customer’s day, we wanted to take a step back and find out which popular cake flavors sweeten and delight us.

We were surprised to get a fresh assortment of favorite cake and frosting flavors from our team, which we’ve shared with you below. Our team’s favorite cake flavor may be your own, or they may surprise you too! If you’re unsure which cake flavor to try, there’s no better testament than the ones coming from the baker’s mouths themselves.

Three votes for our carrot layer cake

The most popular cake flavor from our team was our carrot layer cake with three votes! Our four-layer carrot cake is a classic you can’t go wrong with. Loaded with freshly grated carrots, walnuts, and crushed pineapple, this naturally sweet cake is also incredibly moist. Of course, the icing on top is our cream cheese frosting, which we also fill between each layer to get some frosting with every bite.

With a carrot cake, you typically know what to expect, but by using the freshest ingredients and specially packaging the cakes with dry ice, we are able to deliver a rich and balanced treat – as if it came straight out of the oven.

Golden butter vanilla cake with different frosting favorites

Our golden butter vanilla cake received two votes – one with vanilla cream filling, the other with our chocolate cream cheese frosting. These two team members also mentioned that they enjoyed the golden butter vanilla cake with our strawberry cream cheese frosting as well.

With so many different frostings to choose from, both our employees and customers can enjoy these moist, fluffy layers of our classic golden butter vanilla and personalize it to perfection with their favorite frostings.

Other favorite cake flavors

Outside of our carrot layer cake and golden butter cake, the following are popular cake flavors that received one vote each from our team members:

  • Cookies and cream layer cake
  • Chocolate chip banana Bundt
  • Strawberry layer cake with fresh strawberries
  • Almond cake with fresh strawberries and vanilla cream cheese frosting
  • Lemon layer
  • Coconut cake
  • Key lime pie

It was so interesting to find that each of our team members had their own favorite cake and frosting combination that was so different from the other. I guess that’s what happens when you have so many different combinations of cake flavors, frostings, and toppings to choose from.

Honorable mention cake flavors and frostings

While everyone picked something different, several commented on how much they liked our strawberry cream cheese frosting and fresh strawberry layer cake – though it was not listed as a favorite. Based on these comments, we give this popular cake flavor an honorable mention!

Our chocolate layer cake also gets an honorable mention because it’s a favorite of our fans – our top selling flavor since 1997 – yet not picked as a favorite by our team! Maybe they’re sick of making them so much. In fact, InStyle Magazine chose this fabulous chocolate cake as the Best Mail Order Cake.

We are also known for our key lime Bundt cake. Ever since Oprah Winfrey chose it as one of her “Favorite Things,” this has been one of our best cake flavors and is always in high demand.

With so many great cake flavors to choose from, you’ll have to decide for yourself!

Our staff loves when we introduce new seasonal flavors, but it’s almost impossible for our loyal customers to try and keep up with it all. That’s why we introduced our Cake of the Month club (six or 12 months) where a different delicious cake is delivered for your clients, friends, family, or even YOU, each and every month. Get a taste of our cake of the month, every month, and decide for yourself which flavor, frosting, and topping is your own personal favorite.

Do you already think you have a favorite flavor? We’d love to hear from you on what cake has taken a piece of your heart. At We Take The Cake, cake isn’t just a dessert, it’s a symbol of celebration, happiness, friends, and family. That’s why we take so much care in creating the most splendid and delectable cakes and cupcakes because we know what it means to you. And nothing brings us more joy than hearing what you think!