Beautiful Baby Shower Cakes: Custom-Made for Your Special Day

BAKED SPECIFICALLY FOR YOUR OCCASION

At the center of this special gathering is often a beautiful baby shower cake that serves both as a delicious treat and a focal point for the celebration. At We Take The Cake, we understand that baby showers are treasured moments where friends and family gather to celebrate the soon-to-arrive bundle of joy. Our expert cake artisans craft each baby shower cake with meticulous attention to detail, using only the finest ingredients—whole buttermilk, fresh eggs, and real butter—never cake mixes or commercially made frostings. With your dessert needs in expert hands, you can focus on other aspects of hosting and enjoying the special celebration.

On this page, you’ll discover our collection of cakes perfect for baby showers, learn about our custom cake options, explore delivery options, and find answers to frequently asked questions about ordering your perfect baby shower cake.

Pricing

Nationwide Shipping:

See each cake for more information

Baby Shower Cake Options

Choosing the perfect baby shower cake is all about finding a design and flavor that complements your celebration. We offer several options perfect for welcoming a little one:

Golden Butter Layer Cake

This timeless cake features four rich layers of vanilla cake with creamy vanilla cream cheese filling and frosting. The elegant buttercream decorations make it ideal for traditional or gender-neutral baby showers, serving 8-10 guests.

4-Layer Fresh Strawberry Cake

Celebrate with this beautiful pink creation featuring strawberry-flavored cake layers and fresh strawberry slices. White chocolate drip and strawberry preserve accents add sophisticated appeal to this fruity, crowd-pleasing dessert.

Chocolate 4-Layer Cake with Pink Roses

Make a stunning statement with a rich chocolate cake adorned with hand-piped pink buttercream roses. Four decadent layers filled with chocolate cream cheese create an elegant centerpiece for sophisticated celebrations.

Brownie Cheesecake 4-Layer Cake

Indulge in four desserts in one with this showstopper featuring a fudgy brownie base, cheesecake, chocolate mousse, and chocolate cake layers. Decorated with buttercream stripes and brownie pieces for a sophisticated yet playful finish.

Famous Key Lime Bundt Cake

This tangy, refreshing bundt cake provides a unique option for baby showers. Made with freshly squeezed key lime juice and topped with a zesty glaze, it offers a bright, memorable flavor that stands out from traditional choices.

Bouquet Cupcakes

Offer individual servings with our set of eight flower-topped cupcakes. These artistic creations include four chocolate and four golden butter cupcakes in green tulip wrappers, providing a convenient alternative to traditional cake.

No matter which baby shower cake you select, each is crafted with the same attention to detail and quality ingredients that have made We Take The Cake a trusted name for life’s special celebrations. Your guests will enjoy both a beautiful presentation and a homemade taste.

Custom Baby Shower Cake Orders

Ordering a custom baby shower cake is simple:

Review our products on WeTakeTheCake.com to get acquainted with our style and offerings
Reach out to our Custom Dessert Consultants at concierge@goldbelly.com to discuss your ideas and set up a plan
Receive a beautiful, custom-made cake that perfectly complements your baby shower

Our custom designs can incorporate colors that celebrate the baby’s gender, include personalized messages, or feature themed decorations that coordinate with your shower. We recommend contacting us at least two weeks before your event for custom orders to ensure we can accommodate your specific requests.

Delivery Options

Whether you’re hosting a baby shower locally or sending sweet congratulations across the country, we make it easy to include a beautiful cake in the celebration. Our baby shower cake collection is accessible to everyone through shipping options, bringing handcrafted joy to welcoming parties everywhere.

Nationwide Shipping

We Take The Cake ships our beautiful baby shower cakes nationwide throughout the United States and Canada through our partnership with Goldbelly. Our experienced shipping team carefully packages each cake in decorative boxes that protect your dessert while maintaining its beautiful presentation.For optimal freshness and appearance, we recommend placing your baby shower cake order at least 5-7 business days before your event. This timeline allows for baking, decorating, shipping, and delivery to ensure your cake arrives in perfect condition for the celebration. Our cakes are shipped frozen to preserve their quality and typically arrive within 1-2 days of shipping, depending on your location.

The Sweet Art of Celebration

For more than 20 years, We Take The Cake has created handcrafted, artisan desserts that help people celebrate life’s special moments. Our diverse team works closely together each day, mixing batters and frostings by hand just like grandma used to make, using only the finest ingredients—never cake mixes or commercially prepared frostings.Beyond baby shower cakes, our bakery offers a variety of desserts to mark all of life’s important occasions:

Classic 4-Layer Cakes: Our signature offerings in flavors like Chocolate, Golden Butter, Coconut, and Lemon
Celebration Birthday Cakes: Festive designs complete with “Happy Birthday” plaques and candles
Seasonal and Holiday Cakes: Special creations for Christmas, Valentine’s Day, Halloween, and other holidays
Bundt Cakes: Including our famous Key Lime and rich Chocolate Fudge varieties

We live our mission every day: to help people celebrate, commemorate, appreciate, and send a message of love through the joy of cake. We look forward to being part of your baby shower celebration.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you accommodate dietary restrictions for baby shower cakes?

Yes, we offer gluten-free and vegan options for those with dietary restrictions. Please note these cakes are made in a facility that also produces items containing gluten, nuts, and other allergens.

How are the cakes packaged for shipping?

Our cakes are carefully frozen and then packaged in boxes with insulation and ice packs to maintain optimal temperature during transit. Each cake arrives ready to thaw and enjoy.