Handcrafted Fall Cakes: Seasonal Flavors to Celebrate Autumn

BAKED SPECIFICALLY FOR YOUR OCCASION

At We Take The Cake, fall means harvest-rich flavors and heartwarming celebrations. Our fall cake collection features only the finest ingredients—real butter, fresh eggs, and whole buttermilk—never commercial mixes or pre-made frostings. Each cake is meticulously crafted by hand, just like grandma used to make, creating desserts that transform ordinary autumn moments into extraordinary memories. Whether for a festive Thanksgiving table, a Halloween gathering, or simply to savor the season’s warmth, our handcrafted fall cakes deliver the authentic tastes of autumn directly to your door, ready to delight family and friends with every bite.

Pricing

LOCAL PICKUP:

See each cake for more information

Nationwide Shipping:

See each cake for more information

Our Signature Fall Collection

Fall deserves to be celebrated with desserts as rich and vibrant as the season itself. Our signature collection features handcrafted cakes that showcase seasonal flavors—from earthly pumpkin and warm spices to rich chocolate and comforting classics.

Pumpkin Maple Bundt Cake

This moist, spiced cake captures autumn’s essence with freshly pureed pumpkin, warming cinnamon, and allspice. The included cream cheese glaze creates a delicious finish that pairs perfectly with a steaming cup of coffee on a crisp fall day.

Classic Pumpkin Layer Cake

Our beloved four-layer creation features tender, spiced pumpkin cake made with real pumpkin puree and filled with smooth cream cheese. The elegant decoration of pumpkin cake crumbs and buttercream accents makes this a stunning centerpiece for any Thanksgiving table.

Halloween Ghost Layer Cake

This playful creation alternates layers of chocolate and golden butter cake filled with rich chocolate cream cheese. Dramatically frosted with black buttercream and crowned with friendly ghosts, it brings whimsical spirit to Halloween festivities.

Carrot 3-Layer Cake

Three moist layers flecked with freshly shredded carrots, crushed pineapple, and walnuts create comforting autumn warmth. Generously filled and frosted with velvety vanilla cream cheese, this cake brings cozy spice notes to cool fall days.

Chocolate Fudge Bundt

This dense, fudgy cake studded with semi-sweet chocolate chips delivers rich indulgence for autumn evenings. The included chocolate cream cheese frosting can be warmed and drizzled over each slice for a decadent chocolate experience that satisfies fall comfort food cravings.

Peanut Butter Cup 4-Layer Cake

The classic combination of chocolate cake and peanut butter buttercream creates an irresistible fall comfort dessert. Artistic touches of ganache, yellow buttercream, and mini peanut butter cups transform this flavor pairing into an indulgent autumn showstopper.

From kitchen to table, each cake in our fall collection brings something special to your autumn celebrations. Whether enjoyed with morning coffee, as a weeknight treat, or as the grand finale to a holiday feast, these handcrafted desserts do more than satisfy a sweet tooth—they bring people together around flavors that define the season.


The Perfect Occasions for Fall Cakes

Our fall cake collection adds a special touch to any autumn celebration. Here are just a few occasions where our handcrafted fall cakes can elevate your experience:

  • Thanksgiving Gatherings: Complete your holiday feast with a stunning fall cake centerpiece that captures the season’s bounty and gratitude.
  • Halloween Celebrations: Make your spooky soirées memorable with our playful Halloween Ghost Layer Cake or any of our fall classics.
  • Fall Birthday Cakes: Celebrate autumn birthdays with seasonal flavors that bring warmth and comfort to your special day.
  • Harvest Festivals: Mark the season’s abundance with desserts that showcase fall’s most beloved flavors.
  • Football Game Watch Parties: Score big with your fellow fans by serving our fall cakes during the game. Their shareable size and crowd-pleasing flavors make them the perfect halftime highlight or victory celebration treat.
  • Fall Corporate Events: Send appreciation to clients and colleagues with our elegant fall cakes for autumn business functions.
  • Long-Distance Love: Share the joy of fall with family and friends nationwide when you can’t be there in person to celebrate the season together.

Fall Cake Delivery: From Our Bakery to Your Celebration

With our convenient delivery and pickup options, we can bring the rich flavors of fall to any table. Our fall cake collection is available nationwide, ensuring everyone can experience these seasonal handcrafted delights.

Fort Lauderdale Local Pickup

For those in South Florida, visit our bakery to collect your fall creation in person:

  • Reserve your fall cake by calling (954) 764-2253 (CAKE)
  • Stop by our bakery at 1211 N.E. 9th Ave, Fort Lauderdale, FL 33304
  • Available Monday – Friday, 9am – 4:30pm (closed weekends)
  • Take home your freshly made fall dessert, ready to serve

Nationwide Delivery

Distance is no obstacle to enjoying our seasonal specialties! We’ve partnered with Goldbelly to ship our fall cakes throughout the United States and Canada, perfect for surprising faraway loved ones or treating yourself.

Our specially designed packaging preserves all the delicate flavors and beautiful decorations that make our fall cakes special. Each cake is carefully prepared, flash-frozen, and shipped with temperature control to maintain bakery-fresh quality.

Upon Delivery:

  • Desserts arrive frozen with dry ice for optimal freshness
  • Use caution when handling packaging with dry ice
  • Store unopened in freezer for up to 3 months
  • Thaw in the refrigerator when ready to enjoy
  • Bring to room temperature before serving

About We Take The Cake

Since 1997, We Take The Cake has been creating moments of celebration through our handcrafted desserts in Fort Lauderdale. While our fall collection showcases autumn’s distinctive flavors, it represents just one facet of our year-round dedication to seasonal excellence. Throughout the calendar, we offer specially crafted cakes that capture each season’s unique character—from fresh spring cakes to bright summer cakes, alongside our classic celebration cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, and more.

What truly matters to us is being part of your special moments throughout the year, whether you’re gathering around a Thanksgiving table, celebrating a birthday, or sharing joy with loved ones across the country. Each creation shares our commitment to premium ingredients—farm-fresh eggs, real butter, and whole buttermilk—mixed by hand using traditional methods that honor the art of baking.


Frequently Asked Questions

How many people do the fall cakes serve?

Our fall layer cakes serve 8-12 people, making them perfect for family gatherings and small parties. Fall bundt cakes serve 8 people, offering a more intimate dessert option while still providing enough for everyone to enjoy seconds.

Can I order fall cakes in advance for seasonal celebrations?

We recommend ordering fall cakes 1-2 weeks in advance to ensure availability, especially during peak autumn holidays like Thanksgiving and Halloween. Early ordering secures your preferred delivery date and ensures you won’t miss out on seasonal favorites that often sell out quickly.