Birthday celebrations deserve something truly special, and We Take The Cake creates handcrafted birthday cakes that make every moment memorable. Our artisan bakers have been crafting made-from-scratch birthday cakes for over 20 years, mixing every batter and frosting by hand just like grandma used to make. With nationwide shipping to the continental United States and Canada, we make it possible to send a slice of celebration to your loved ones wherever they are. Whether you’re planning an autumn gathering or celebrating any time of year, our four birthday cake options offer something perfect for every taste and dietary need.
Our Fall Birthday Cake Collection
Our birthday cake collection features four delicious options, each handcrafted with care and decorated to make your celebration special. Choose from these made-from-scratch options:
- Golden Butter Vanilla Birthday Cake: Four layers of moist golden butter cake filled and frosted with velvety vanilla buttercream. Hand-piped with colorful buttercream details and includes a “Happy Birthday” plaque and candles for the perfect classic celebration.
- Prize-Winning Chocolate Birthday Cake: Our bestselling chocolate cake since 1997 features four layers of rich chocolate buttermilk cake with signature chocolate cream cheese frosting. Decorated with festive buttercream details, this indulgent option is ideal for chocolate lovers.
- Gluten-Free Golden Butter Vanilla Birthday Cake: Four layers of gluten-free golden butter cake with smooth vanilla buttercream throughout. Features a bold buttercream design with “Happy Birthday” plaque and candles, proving gluten-free can be just as delicious.
- Gluten-Free Chocolate Birthday Cake: Rich gluten-free chocolate cake layered with our signature chocolate cream cheese frosting. Adorned with festive buttercream design and complete with birthday accessories for a perfect gluten-free celebration.
Each cake arrives ready to serve in our beautiful branded packaging, so you can focus on what matters most—celebrating with the people you love. With the dessert handled, all that’s left is gathering around the table and making memories that last long after the last bite.
Why Choose We Take The Cake for Fall Birthday Celebrations
Our handcrafted approach makes all the difference for your special celebration:
- Real Ingredients Only: We use whole buttermilk, fresh eggs, and real butter—never cake mixes or commercially made frostings.
- Artisan Decoration: Our talented cake artisans hand-pipe every buttercream detail to make each cake visually stunning.
- Reliable Shipping: Custom-designed boxes preserve freshness and presentation during nationwide delivery.
- 20+ Years of Experience: We’ve been helping families celebrate life’s important moments since our founding.
- Distance Celebrations: Perfect for sending love when you can’t be there to celebrate in person.
Whether you’re hosting locally or sending across the country, our cakes arrive ready to become the centerpiece of any autumn birthday celebration.
Get Your Fall Birthday Cake: Convenient Nationwide Shipping
We Take The Cake makes it easy for you to enjoy our delightful birthday cakes no matter where you are. We offer nationwide shipping through Goldbelly to the continental United States and Canada for just $89.95 with free standard shipping.
Your cake will be carefully packaged to maintain its freshness during transit. Our meticulous shipping process means that your cake will taste as delicious as if you had picked it up directly from our bakery. Upon arrival, store your cake in the freezer for up to 3 months or in the refrigerator for up to 7 days. We recommend ordering 7-10 days before your celebration to allow time for shipping and proper storage.
All our birthday cakes measure 6 inches in diameter and stand 4 inches tall, generously serving 8-10 people—perfect for intimate fall gatherings.
Serving and Storing Your Fall Birthday Cake
Display your fall birthday cake on a stand to show off its beautiful layers and hand-piped decorations. For the best flavor and texture, allow the cake to come to room temperature before serving, which takes about 2-3 hours if frozen.
To achieve perfect, clean slices:
- Warm a knife blade under hot water.
- Dry the knife thoroughly before each slice.
- Wipe the blade clean between cuts for a tidy presentation.
Store any leftover cake in an airtight container in the refrigerator to keep it fresh. When you’re ready to indulge again, simply let the cake return to room temperature for the best taste and texture.
Explore Our Complete Dessert Collection
While our birthday cakes are perfect for fall celebrations, We Take The Cake offers an extensive collection of handcrafted desserts for every occasion:
- Classic 4-Layer Cakes: Fresh strawberry, lemon, coconut, carrot, and more cakes made with the same quality ingredients and attention to detail as our birthday options.
- Holiday and Seasonal Cakes: Special themed cakes for Valentine’s Day, Mother’s Day, Halloween, Christmas, and other celebrations throughout the year.
- Specialty Desserts: Unique creations like our Brownie Cheesecake, Tres Leches cake, Mini Cakes featuring brownie-cheesecake and strawberry combinations, and stunning Bouquet Cupcakes with hand-piped buttercream flowers.
- Bundt Cakes: Our famous Key Lime Bundt that made Oprah’s “Favorite Things” list.
Our diverse collection ensures there’s always the perfect handcrafted dessert ready to make your moment special. From birthdays and holidays to those spontaneous moments when you want to brighten someone’s day, we have something delicious waiting for you.
Frequently Asked Questions
How far in advance should I order for fall birthdays?
We recommend ordering 7-10 days in advance for our nationwide shipping, especially during the busy autumn celebration season.
Do the cakes arrive fresh for autumn celebrations?
Absolutely! Our careful packaging and shipping process means your cake arrives fresh and ready to enjoy, tasting just as delicious as if you picked it up from our bakery.
Can I send these as gifts to family celebrating fall birthdays?
Yes! Nationwide shipping makes it easy to surprise loved ones with a thoughtful birthday cake delivery, complete with beautiful packaging that shows you care.
How do I store my cake once it arrives?
Store in the refrigerator for up to 7 days or freeze for up to 3 months. Let frozen cakes thaw at room temperature for 2-3 hours before serving for the best taste and texture.